Guide · prop firm comparison
Lucid Trading vs Topstep: which evaluations strategies passed live
Real live results from finished evaluations on both firms, with each firm's published rules for the same account sizes.
14Lucid Trading passes
7Topstep passes
2Lucid Trading fails
0Topstep fails
Live record side by side
| As of Nov 1, 2026 | Lucid Trading | Topstep |
|---|---|---|
| Live passes | 14 | 7 |
| Fails | 2 | 0 |
| Strategies that passed | 8 | 4 |
| Packages with passes | 5 | 5 |
| Median trading days to pass | 2.0 | 2 |
| Fastest pass (trading days) | 1 | 2 |
Lucid Trading has more recorded live passes in the PropPass directory today (14 vs 7). The count depends on how many strategies are running on each firm's packages, so compare the pass-to-fail balance as well as the totals.
Recorded live on a virtual evaluation account. Finished evaluations only.
Evaluation rules by account size
For each size, the plan with the most live passes (or the firm's plan of that size). Lucid Trading rules as of 2026-09-11; Topstep rules as of 2026-10-03.
25K evaluations
| Rule | Lucid Trading | Topstep |
|---|---|---|
| Plan | LucidPro | Labs $25K Static Combine (XFA Standard) |
| Account size | $25,000 | $25,000 |
| Profit target | $1,250 | $2,000 |
| Maximum loss (drawdown) | $1,000 · End-of-day trailing | $1,000 · Static (does not move) |
| Daily loss limit | $600 (optional — only if added at purchase) · trading pauses for the rest of the day | $500 · trading pauses for the rest of the day |
| Consistency rule | None in the evaluation | Best day ≤ 55% of total profit, or the profit target rises |
| Minimum trading days | 1 trading day | None |
| Time limit | No time limit | 90 calendar days |
| Flat by | 4:45 PM ET | 4:10 PM ET |
50K evaluations
| Rule | Lucid Trading | Topstep |
|---|---|---|
| Plan | LucidPro | Trading Combine (XFA Standard) |
| Account size | $50,000 | $50,000 |
| Profit target | $3,000 | $3,000 |
| Maximum loss (drawdown) | $2,000 · End-of-day trailing | $2,000 · End-of-day trailing |
| Daily loss limit | $1,200 (optional — only if added at purchase) · trading pauses for the rest of the day | $1,000 (optional — only if added at purchase) · trading pauses for the rest of the day |
| Consistency rule | None in the evaluation | Best day ≤ 55% of total profit, or the profit target rises |
| Minimum trading days | 1 trading day | None |
| Time limit | No time limit | No time limit |
| Flat by | 4:45 PM ET | 4:10 PM ET |
100K evaluations
| Rule | Lucid Trading | Topstep |
|---|---|---|
| Plan | LucidMaxx | Trading Combine (XFA Consistency) |
| Account size | $100,000 | $100,000 |
| Profit target | $6,000 | $6,000 |
| Maximum loss (drawdown) | $3,000 · Not published as trailing or static | $3,000 · End-of-day trailing |
| Daily loss limit | None | $2,000 (optional — only if added at purchase) · trading pauses for the rest of the day |
| Consistency rule | Best day must be ≤ 40% of total profit to pass | Best day ≤ 55% of total profit, or the profit target rises |
| Minimum trading days | 5 trading days | None |
| Time limit | No time limit | No time limit |
| Flat by | 4:45 PM ET | 4:10 PM ET |
150K evaluations
| Rule | Lucid Trading | Topstep |
|---|---|---|
| Plan | LucidPro | Trading Combine (XFA Consistency) |
| Account size | $150,000 | $150,000 |
| Profit target | $9,000 | $9,000 |
| Maximum loss (drawdown) | $4,500 · End-of-day trailing | $4,500 · End-of-day trailing |
| Daily loss limit | $2,700 (optional — only if added at purchase) · trading pauses for the rest of the day | $3,000 (optional — only if added at purchase) · trading pauses for the rest of the day |
| Consistency rule | None in the evaluation | Best day ≤ 55% of total profit, or the profit target rises |
| Minimum trading days | 1 trading day | None |
| Time limit | No time limit | No time limit |
| Flat by | 4:45 PM ET | 4:10 PM ET |
Ready to pass your next evaluation?
Pick a strategy or bot built for your prop firm and your exact package, with a real record of passed evaluations. Run it on your own NinjaTrader account or follow its alerts.
News rules
| Lucid Trading | Topstep | |
|---|---|---|
| News | News trading is allowed on LucidPro, LucidFlex and LucidDirect; it is prohibited on LucidDaily. | Allowed with limits: trading maximum size into major news is prohibited, and around CPI releases new opening trades in index and metal minis are paused for 5 minutes either side. |
How PropPass works: PropPass strategies run on your own NinjaTrader, or you can follow a strategy's alerts by web, Telegram, SMS or app push notification.
Lucid Trading packages with live passes
- Lucid Trading LucidMaxx 25K — 1 passes, 0 fails
- Lucid Trading LucidMaxx 100K — 1 passes, 0 fails
- Lucid Trading LucidPro 25K — 5 passes, 1 fails
- Lucid Trading LucidPro 50K — 6 passes, 1 fails
- Lucid Trading LucidPro 150K — 1 passes, 0 fails
Topstep packages with live passes
- Topstep Labs $250K Freedom Combine (XFA Standard) 250K — 1 passes, 0 fails
- Topstep Trading Combine (XFA Consistency) 100K — 2 passes, 0 fails
- Topstep Trading Combine (XFA Consistency) 150K — 1 passes, 0 fails
- Topstep Trading Combine (XFA Standard) 100K — 2 passes, 0 fails
- Topstep Trading Combine (XFA Standard) 150K — 1 passes, 0 fails
Questions traders ask
Has any strategy passed a Topstep evaluation live?
Yes. As of Nov 1, 2026, 4 strategies in the PropPass directory have passed Topstep evaluations live: 7 passes and 0 fails across 5 packages. Every result is a finished evaluation recorded live on a virtual evaluation account. See every Topstep pass.
Has any strategy passed a Lucid Trading evaluation live?
Yes. As of Nov 1, 2026, 8 strategies in the PropPass directory have passed Lucid Trading evaluations live: 14 passes and 2 fails across 5 packages. Every result is a finished evaluation recorded live on a virtual evaluation account. See every Lucid Trading pass.
Which Topstep packages have strategies passed?
Live passes by package as of Nov 1, 2026: Trading Combine (XFA Standard) 100K: 2 passes; Trading Combine (XFA Consistency) 100K: 2 passes; Labs $250K Freedom Combine (XFA Standard) 250K: 1 pass; Trading Combine (XFA Standard) 150K: 1 pass; Trading Combine (XFA Consistency) 150K: 1 pass.
Which futures did the strategies that passed Topstep trade?
Passes by instrument as of Nov 1, 2026: Silver (SI): 4; E-mini Nasdaq-100 (NQ): 2; Micro E-mini Dow (MYM): 1.
How long does it take to pass Topstep?
Among the 7 live passes recorded on Topstep evaluations, the median was 2 trading days; the fastest took 2 and the longest 5. Firm minimum-day rules apply.
What are the Topstep Trading Combine (XFA Standard) 100K evaluation rules?
The Topstep Trading Combine (XFA Standard) 100K evaluation has a $6,000 profit target; the maximum loss is $3,000: the account fails if the balance falls to $97,000 at the start, and that level rises with each higher end-of-day balance; it no longer rises once it reaches $100,000. Daily loss limit: $2,000 (optional — only if added at purchase) · trading pauses for the rest of the day. Consistency: best day ≤ 55% of total profit, or the profit target rises. Positions must be flat by 4:10 PM ET. (As of 2026-10-03.) Rules and live passes for this package.
More questions traders ask
Which Lucid Trading packages have strategies passed?
Live passes by package as of Nov 1, 2026: LucidPro 50K: 6 passes; LucidPro 25K: 5 passes; LucidPro 150K: 1 pass; LucidMaxx 100K: 1 pass; LucidMaxx 25K: 1 pass.
Which futures did the strategies that passed Lucid Trading trade?
Passes by instrument as of Nov 1, 2026: Micro E-mini Nasdaq-100 (MNQ): 5; E-mini Nasdaq-100 (NQ): 4; E-mini Dow (YM): 2; Silver (SI): 2; Gold (GC): 1.
How do PropPass strategies work for Topstep evaluations?
Each strategy is built for a specific firm package and shows its finished live record. PropPass strategies run on your own NinjaTrader, or you can follow a strategy's alerts by web, Telegram, SMS or app push notification.
How do PropPass strategies and bots work?
Each PropPass strategy is built for a specific prop firm package and shows its record of finished live evaluations. PropPass strategies run on your own NinjaTrader, or you can follow a strategy's alerts by web, Telegram, SMS or app push notification.
What time do Topstep positions have to be closed?
Topstep evaluations must be flat by 4:10 PM ET each trading day, per the firm's rules as of 2026-10-03.
Lucid Trading vs Topstep: which evaluations did strategies pass live?
As of Nov 1, 2026: Lucid Trading — 14 passes, 2 fails across 5 packages; Topstep — 7 passes, 0 fails across 5 packages. All are finished evaluations recorded live on virtual evaluation accounts.